Addressing the Issue of Mischaracterized Materials
Interview with Bill Hargin as published in DesignNews:
Two engineers have advice for engineers who need more accurate characterization of PCB laminate materials: Make your own measurements.
Engineers who use laminate materials for printed circuit boards need to be aware that the manufacturers’ numbers describing those materials may not always be correct.
“The buyer needs to be aware,” Bill Hargin, director of everything for Z-zero, LP, told Design News. “If the laminate manufacturer is giving you numbers that are 20% away from reality, that might be something you want to avoid.”
Hargin, along with CCN president Don DeGroot emphasize the importance of this message for users of copper-clad laminate materials. Misleading characterizations can lead to signal and power integrity issues in circuit boards. In many cases, engineers are unknowingly introducing uncertainty into their designs, they said.
Two parameters—the dielectric constant (Dk) and the loss tangent (Df)—are particularly important and often mischaracterized in the tables published by material manufacturers, they added. “We’ve seen some materials that match up on the dielectric constant, but miss on the loss tangent,” DeGroot said. “And we’ve seen other materials that match up on the loss tangent, but miss on the dielectric constant. Not all of the data is bad, but you need to know that you can’t just plug in the numbers from the tables.”
Hargin and DeGroot discuss the need for engineers to make their own measurements. Their two companies are teaming up on a methodology that would enable engineers to do that in a simple and accessible way. “We’re not inventing a new method,” DeGroot said. “We’re making a modification to an existing IPC test method. And we’re making it in such a way that people can put a slip of material in a clamp, hit a button, and be assured they are getting the right answer.”
In essence, Hargin and DeGroot are aiming to clear up some of the mystery that surrounds materials testing. Today, they said, there are too many methods for characterizing the dielectric constant and loss tangent of a material. As a result, engineers are often hesitant to make the measurements themselves because they’re not sure which method to use. “It’s like the wild, wild West out there right now,” Hargin told us.
Their goal is to make engineers aware of the potential problems, as well as the solutions. “The thing that every engineer needs to be ‘woked’ to is that their numbers aren’t always matching,” DeGroot said. “You need better data. And how do you get that data? Do it yourself.”
Senior technical editor Chuck Murray has been writing about technology for 34 years. He joined Design News in 1987, and has covered electronics, automation, fluid power, and auto.
This article was originally published by Charles Murray, DesignNews, Nov 30, 2018